The Dangers of Soap Opera Thinking in Long-Running Stories
- Story Marc
- Mar 18
- 3 min read
Updated: Mar 20
The longer a story runs, the more likely it is to fall victim to what I call soap opera thinking—a mode of storytelling that prioritizes constant escalation, shocking twists, and melodrama at the expense of coherence and character integrity. While this approach can sustain short-term engagement, it often leads to terrible creative decisions that undermine the core of a story.
Why Does Soap Opera Thinking Take Over?
1. The Need to Keep Things "Exciting"
In a long-running story—whether a TV show, book series, or serialized manga—there’s an inherent pressure to maintain audience interest. Instead of finding organic ways to expand the world or deepen the conflict, writers may resort to escalation for escalation’s sake. This often results in:
Characters constantly betraying each other to create artificial tension.
Deaths, resurrections, and fake-outs that diminish stakes.
Conflicts being prolonged through misunderstandings and contrivances rather than meaningful opposition.
2. Over-Reliance on Relationship Drama
Soap opera thinking assumes audiences will stay invested if the characters are always in emotional turmoil. When external conflict stagnates, long-running stories often fall back on needless interpersonal betrayals, forced breakups, or endless love triangles. The result?
Character relationships feel like gimmicks rather than genuine connections.
Once-solid romances are arbitrarily sabotaged for "fresh drama."
Characters flip-flop in their loyalties and affections, creating narrative inconsistency.
3. Twist Addiction
Soap opera logic operates under the belief that more twists = better storytelling. While surprises can be powerful, twists for the sake of shock value often lead to:
Characters behaving inconsistently just to serve the plot.
Major revelations that contradict established lore (e.g., a sudden evil twin, secret royal heritage, or a character’s past being rewritten).
Desensitization—when every plot point is a twist, nothing is surprising anymore.
4. Forgetting What Made the Story Work
As a series stretches on, writers sometimes lose sight of what originally made it compelling. Instead of staying true to the themes, character arcs, and worldbuilding, they start thinking in terms of maximum drama per episode/season/arc. This leads to:
Good characters making idiotic decisions just to create tension.
The core conflict being replaced with never-ending side drama.
Previously meaningful arcs being undermined by unnecessary extensions.
5. Character Assassination for Drama’s Sake
A hallmark of soap opera thinking is ruining well-developed characters to force conflict. This can take many forms, such as:
A hero suddenly turning evil without proper buildup.
A character being unreasonably vilified or killed off for shock value.
Previously competent characters becoming inexplicably dumb or reckless to create artificial stakes.
An established romantic relationship being randomly destroyed for the sake of new tension.
Examples of Soap Opera Thinking Ruining Stories
Game of Thrones (Final Seasons) → Prioritizing "shocking" moments (Daenerys’ sudden descent into madness, Arya killing the Night King with no buildup) over well-earned character arcs.
The Flash (CW) → The same cycle of Barry and Iris breaking up and reuniting repeatedly for artificial drama.
The Walking Dead (Post-Negan) → Overuse of fake-out deaths, convoluted betrayals, and dragging-out storylines that lost sight of the survival horror premise.
How to Avoid Soap Opera Thinking
1. Stick to Core Themes
Every major event should serve the core conflict and character arcs, not just exist for shock value. Ask: Does this twist deepen the story’s themes, or is it just drama for drama’s sake?
2. Maintain Character Integrity
Avoid plot developments that require a character to suddenly become dumb, evil, or inconsistent without genuine buildup. Good stories respect character motivations and arcs.
3. Pay Attention to Long-Term Payoff
Good storytelling is about earned resolutions, not short-term gasps. Twists and conflicts should lead to meaningful consequences rather than being dropped once the shock wears off.
4. Know When to End the Story
Some stories get ruined simply because they outstay their natural lifespan. If a narrative is forced to continue beyond its logical conclusion, contrivances and forced drama become inevitable. A strong, well-planned ending is always better than dragging things out.
Final Thoughts
Soap opera thinking thrives on short-term excitement but long-term damage. While it can create temporary engagement, it ultimately cheapens character arcs, undermines narrative integrity, and makes audiences stop taking the story seriously. The best long-running stories maintain their vision, character consistency, and thematic depth, rather than resorting to hollow sensationalism.
If your story starts leaning on cheap twists, forced betrayals, and endless love triangles, it’s time to ask: Am I telling a compelling story, or just chasing drama?
Comments